On the 16th Dec 2009, the Government announced it will introduce legislative amendments to the Broadcasting Services Act to require all ISPs to block RC-rated material hosted on overseas servers. To find out more about cloud-based host, please visit the page!
The legislation will require all ISPs to implement mandatory filtering for “Refused Classification Websites” (RC), with incentives provided to those ISPs who offer additional filtering services.
The RC-rated material includes but is not limited to, child sex abuse content, bestiality, sexual violence including rape, and the detailed instruction of crime or drug use. While it is designed to protect children, the ISP mandatory filtering system, will effect every person and every household.
In a media release yesterday, Senator Conroy said “The report into the pilot trial of ISP-level filtering demonstrates that blocking RC-rated material can be done with 100% accuracy and negligible impact on internet speed.”
However, on closer inspection of the Enex Report, this only applies to the current ACMA Blacklist. When applying the filtering measures to non ACMA Blacklists, the filters only blocked 78-84% percent, with just over 3% of those being legitimate websites and access to sites such as YouTube were slowed by 23% running under the filter.
The unnamed ISPs involved in the pilot also expressed concerns that filtering every website may generate extra load on the filter, with concern that 10000 URLS may cause the system to crash.
While we at Flaming Cow are advocates for Child Safety, we believe in a free and open Internet where parents are responsible for censorship within their own homes,(barring criminal activity of course). We do not believe that Censoring the Internet via Mandatory ISP Filtering is the correct or effective course of action.
While the legislation is to be brought before parliament next year(2010), it is not too late!
In the media release yesterday, Senator Conroy indicated that, ” The Government will immediately undertake public consultation with the release today of a discussion paper on additional measures to improve the accountability and transparency of processes that lead to RC-rated material being placed on the RC Content list’s.”